Welcome to Etherbox!
This pad text is synchronized as you type, so that everyone viewing this page sees the same text. Add __NOPUBLISH__ to prevent this pad from being archived.
Queer Analytics
"Queer analytics invites us to wonder together about the potential of microbial, animal, plant, mineral, cosmological technoscience, to situate ourselves in these mundane and alluring scenes, to consider these labours and imagine a collective life otherwise. It asks us to ponder the possibilities and limitations of informatics and to take seriously the affective forces of nonhuman animals and machines. How might we extend queer theories that concern personal injury into more-than-human ensembles, in order to consider the damages shared by humans and nonhumans? How can we generate ways that take us beyond reparative narratives or benevolent utopianism towards more-than-human life?"
Helen Pritchard, Jara Rocha, Laura Benítez. Queering damage: methodologies for partial reparations ... or not (2018)
Operation n: Attunement
Playing soundfiles, tuning to language + voice(s)
https://www.dropbox.com/s/8cwzr4fh13yqmkr/dream.wav?dl=0
Operation n: Situation
https://queeringdamage.hangar.org/index.php/About
https://queeringdamage.hangar.org/index.php/OPERATION_0
Operation n: Bringing damages
"We need you to bring with you one or two experiences of "damage" in the broadest sense. They don't have to be personally experienced injuries: they can be observed damages or collective ones. It can be bodily damage, community damage, environmental damage, personal injury, historical damage, public damage, fictitious damage, cultural damage, file damage, structural damage, naturalized damage, computer damage, urban damage, transgenerational damage, geopolitical damage... etc."
https://queeringdamage.hangar.org/index.php/OPERATION_1
http://etherbox.constantvzw.org/pad/p/queeranalytics.giampilieri
http://etherbox.constantvzw.org/pad/p/queeranalytics.databaseanxiety
http://etherbox.constantvzw.org/pad/p/queeranalytics-treestrainingdamage
Operation n: Questioning damage
-
What is going on here?
-
Which are the agents implied (alive or not, human or not, powerful or powerless)?
-
Wheres (spatiality / situatedness / displacements / distribution)?
-
Whens (temporality / durability / existing / extinct / repeated)?
-
Semiotic-materialities: what signs and matters are at work in this ensemble?
-
Your entanglement with the scene
-
Can a pattern be identified here? To what extent is this damage structural, or singular?
time limit - not more than 20m?
Operation n: Incomplete reading, bibliographic resistance
https://queeringdamage.hangar.org/index.php/READER
Operation n: Subculturing
The (im)possibilities of being with a slime mold, spirit, stone, tree, ...
Operation n: From damage to queer damage, drawing the complexity of a landscape
1. Define your field of interest. Cut apart and together an area of urgency. Set the scene, through naming the fields:
-
ᘒ ፨ ᚼ ⚘ ◊ ᗶ [we're interested to find out how the cutting apart together is expressed/operating in QA. How to notate/account for this]
2. Declare your AE, Entangled Agents (myth, technology, ...). Æ = pH+pNH+pIH+pF --> H - Human, NH - Non human, IH-Inhuman, F - Fantasies/Imaginaries
3. Divide by the axioms of αe (ethics) and αK (Kapital): [dividing as a second cutting? Is this also a cutting apart together?]
4. Where/when: Define the spacetime conditioning: (ephemeral, eternal, cyclic, linear, continuous, eventual, historical present, memory, extincted, dreamed, extended, distributed, dissoluted, dispersed, concentrated, catalized, centrifugal, centripetal, located, situated, regional, local, global, reachable, micro, meso, macro...)
5. Talking about relations. Analyze and notate the Æ through a consideration of its Variable Relations (Ω repair, Δ damage, a affects, E effects, © creative force, ≠ difference)
-
∫ = ^ + ∬ / (xΩ , xΔ, xa, x∃, x©, x≠)
6. Apply at least one Generative Operation for your analysis, to see what it would do. Queering operations.
These are tricky, they require you to take responsibility. Define their scale:
-
>> + i + * + # + " + ♥ + ↺ + ♙ + ♞ + ↺ + ✵ + ⚕
7. declare your QÆ = qH+qNH+qIH+qF+qd, declare the reconfigured entanglement:
-
(tΩ , tΔ, ta, t∃, t©, t≠)
8. Divide by the axioms of αe (ethics) and αK (Kapital)
-
αe
-
[the rest of the formula goes here]
-
αK
9. Name the other end of the equation: [analysis of what the queering of damage can do]
-
QÆ (QUEERING DAMAGE OR N)
-----------------------
GENERATIVE OPERATIONS (potentials for queering; modes of intervention):
>> remediate
^ scale timespace to n
i integrate
* multiply
# speculate
" renarrate
♥ love
↺ protest
♙ resist
♞ reclaim
↻ invent
✵ flip
⚕ celebrate
VARIABLE RELATIONS (a declaration of the relations in your scene of damage that you are you attending to):
Ω repair
Δ damage
a affects
∃ effects
© creative force
≠ difference
AXIOMS
αe axiom of ethics (survival, caretaking, respect, responsability)
αK Kapital (accumulation, acquisition, growth)
FIELDS
ᘒ On the experience and process of damage and pain, partial reparation, loss/disposession
፨ On queer politics and methodologies, contestation, affirmation
ᚼ On contesting anthronormativities
⚘ On bioeconomies, lively capital, accumulation
◊ On computation, analytics, bioinfotech
ᗶ On political fictions, poethics, figurations &/or wild fantasies, opportunities
colonialism
nationalism
Example
αe QUEER ANALYTICS-- OPERATIONS + NONPROFIT EXPERIMENTS -- QUEER ANALYTICS OTHERWISE...OR NOT
ᘒ ፨ ᚼ ◊ ᗶ + ^ + Æ (DAMAGE) / ∫ = ^ + ∬ / (xΩ , xΔ, xa, x∃, x©, x≠) +>> + i+*+ # +" +♥ + ↺+♙+ ♞ + ↺+ ✵+⚕ (tΩ , tΔ, ta, t∃, t©, t≠) = QÆ (QUEERING DAMAGE OR N)
αK SPECIFIC ENTANGLEMENT --- PARTIAL REFIGURED ENTANGLEMENT
https://queeringdamage.hangar.org/index.php/OPERATION_2
Example
αe:
(ᘒ,(≠፨),(≠ᚼ),⚘,◊) + Æ {
(Twins,Parents,Doctors)/ʃT(immediate);(Media,La voluntad de reparación,El pánico ante lo queer)/ʃT(environmental);(Normative anatomy,Psychology,Gender Binary)/ʃT(structural);
} + {
(Twins,Parents,Doctors):(©+Δ);(Media,La voluntad de reparación,El pánico ante lo queer):(∃+Δ+a);(Normative anatomy,Psychology,Gender Binary):(Δ+≠);
} + {
(Twins,Parents,Doctors):("+♞);(Media,La voluntad de reparación,El pánico ante lo queer):(...+♙+");(Normative anatomy,Psychology,Gender Binary):(...,...);
} ??? {
(Twins,Parents,Doctors):(...+...);(Media,La voluntad de reparación,El pánico ante lo queer):(...+...);(Normative anatomy,Psychology,Gender Binary):(...+...);
-
} = QÆ (QUEERING DAMAGE OR N)
:αK
https://queeringdamage.hangar.org/index.php/OPERATION_1#David_Reimer
-----
Æ - this refers to the entangled agents
(Æ = pH+pNH+pIH+pF) <--- ???
H - Human, NH - Non human, IH-Inhuman, F - Fantasies/Imaginaries
QÆ - this refer to the entanged agents after the queer intervention
(QÆ = qH+qNH+qIH+qF+qd) <--- ???
H - Human, NH - Non human, IH-Inhuman, F - Fantasies/Imaginaries
(xΩ , xΔ, xa, x∃, x©, x≠) - this is the long forumula of the (performance of) the entangled agents.
(tΩ , tΔ, ta, t∃, t©, t≠) this is the long formula of the performance of the entangled agents after the queer intervention (QÆ )
So starting from (xΩ , xΔ, xa, x∃, x©, x≠) - this is the long forumula of the (performance of) the entangled agents.
Instead of naming it as the entanglement Æ - we represent it through its material-semtiotic relations that we break down as vairable relations of
X Ω repair
X Δ damage
X a affects
X ∃ effects
X © creative force
X ≠ difference
This assumes that there is a relation of
Ω repair
Δ damage
a affects
∃ effects
© creative force
≠ difference
in each of these entanglements/ensembles.
However this is the mega forumula and we imagined not of all of these always appear in all cases...
Once we make visible this variable relation and its X to analyse and then make a queer intervention on -
so for example if affect is a sigifanct relation in your case - you migt focus on that to make the queering
Therefore after the queer intervention the variable X becomes named as T (after going through a transformation).
NB: We were very uncertain if we were defining these in the right way in the rules of forumula!
+>> + i+*+ # +" +♥ + ↺+♙+ ♞ + ↺+ ✵+⚕
1st session gender blending
constant sessions
2014
proposal : boolean logic gates operators adding one new operator but gate
- but gate : stop the circuit and raises a concern
not go out of the logic system but add some new feature
june 2018
jara rocha +
h
elen pritchard : session age
ing
companions
reflexions on animals hackers
- like cows hacking the milking system, or biocircuit
what it means to age together at different scales : human time, technologies time,
october 2018
hangar
workshop : set several operations
- sound piece : attuning the language / voice - listenning is important
rotting / riotting
-
We wanted to start by sharing some of our starting points and how we came together to think that damage and queering damage could be generative starting points for a conversation with some of the collective activties at Hangar. Jara, Laura and Helen (
=
We) were gathered at the Ageing Companions workshop, at Constant, discussing what it might mean to rot together or to riot together. How we might engage with the processes of damage and being damaged that we were experiencing, witnessing, feeling out, touching on in our practices but also how we might be in conversations with others who were dealing with damage, injury, repair, restoration, composting, speculating, in ways that could hold the damage rather than try to smooth it out, remedy it, hide it, in process of collective reparation.
hold the damage together, as part of the repair itself
communicating about the damage
damage analysis into queer methodology
Some definitions first
-
- Damage - We would like to widen the notion of damage and identify its conditions and surrounding through examples, practices things we come into contact with, and by damage we mean things like: pain, suffering, injury, uselessness, unrevoerability, unreparability, homophobia, racism, ageism, ableims, specism, classism, exclusions, inclusions. Also we are interested in how to make practices that damage .. such as damaging institutions, damaging power structures, damaging fossil fuel economies. --- basically we might have to fuck some shitup.. on the way to repair. but that even with damage sometimes fucking shit up can seem difficult..
-
- Queering : what does it mean? non-identitary, non-essentialist, non-fixed lives // trans*feminist approach: interesctional, not-only-human, antinormative, affirmative...
-
- (partial) Reparation - We want to propose perhaps that we can have some partial hopes to repair some damages but not others, or to live with damage in ways that give comfort and care The semiotic-material lives to which damage happens are complex entanglements. Reparation is not taken here as a developmentalist move nor a progressist technique to keep complexity up and healthy and sharpened no matterhow, but as as basic gesture of trying to organize a togetherness that counts.
-
- Queering Methodologies -- Methodologies: Focus on how we generate data, knowledge, stories, as part of feminist research practices.. Although we are aware that we are a diverse group in which each person's practice might evoke different definitions of method. In other words, how can we, as Octavia Butler might say, uphold a politics of queer survival?
-
- Analytics (discovery, interpretation, and communication of meaningful patterns in data) : post-positive move. A shared word, but many ways to approach that. If you search for analytics online you come across thousands of corporate companies who offer analytical services, services that draw conclusions through running algorithms over data sets, and we feel it is urgent to reclaim analytics in non profit experiments and in processes that might give space to other ways of understanding data, art practice, movement, bodies, thinking with other species, or different types of computation. We can reclaim analytics as the practice of cutting complexity together apart (karen barad). To take on the both the injuries caused by analytics and how they are instrumentalised to provide (situated, temporary) truths about lives living the possible ways of living and also to take on how we might invent/generate/build on an analytics for trans-femisnit work that stays with damage... //
discussions on optimisation
cosmic rays
interferences
0 & 1 is a moment of time and not given
can we imagine flipping bits / floating bits / unstable bits that hesitate between 0 and 1
discretization is not the pb but the fact that it is diconnected from its source
back to karen barad cutting appart
operation 1 trying to index the damages
cf :
https://queeringdamage.hangar.org/index.php/OPERATION_1
invitation to people to bring damage
-
We need you to bring with you one or two experiences of "damage" in the broadest sense. They don't have to be personally experienced injuries: they can be observed damages or collective ones. It can be bodily damage, community damage, environmental damage, personal injury, historical damage, public damage, fictitious damage, cultural damage, file damage, structural damage, naturalized damage, computer damage, urban damage, transgenerational damage, geopolitical damage... etc."
going through a questionnaire, 1 to 1 meeting
-
what is going on here?
-
which are the agents implied?
-
wheres?
-
whens?
-
semiotic-materialities: what signs and matters are at work in this ensemble?
-
your entanglement with the scene ?
-
can a pattern be identified here?
they compile a reader
https://queeringdamage.hangar.org/index.php/READER
legend of semiotics
https://queeringdamage.hangar.org/index.php/OPERATION_2
session was followed by a 1h meeting séance of a slime mold
slime mold
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slime_mold
-- or in french
https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Myxomyc%C3%A8tes
unability to compute
impossibility of the relation
Maryka surprised by the choice of 'damage', to (only) analyse when it already happened.
Preventing damage?
black swann or blank swann
controversy between taieb and ayache
https://www.wiley.com/en-us/The+Blank+Swan%3A+The+End+of+Probability-p-9780470661765
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/7650769-the-blank-swan
Anti-fragility
What does QA do?
Thursday evening:
Related material -
* a book by Sarah Schulman "Conflict is Not Abuse" -
http://blogs.lse.ac.uk/gender/2015/07/07/sarah-schulman-on-conflict-is-not-abuse-rethinking-community-responsibility-outside-of-the-state-apparatus/
* "incorporating the damage into the aesthetic of the restored item, making it part of the object’s history. " =
Kintsukuroi
(金繕い, "golden repair"),[1] is the Japanese art of repairing broken pottery with lacquer dusted or mixed with powdered gold, silver, or platinum, a method similar to the maki-etechnique.[2][3][4] As a philosophy, it treats breakage and repair as part of the history of an object, rather than something to disguise.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kintsugi
(also "In traditional Japanese aesthetics,
wabi-sabi
(侘寂) is a world view centered on the acceptance of transience and imperfection.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wabi-sabi
)
(and Taoistic view of "realitiy being as is, rather then good or bad (or damaged) _
Discussion with SEDA(some randoms notes)
externalities / externalisation
way and purpose of externalisation, standardisation
holding damage
annotation of data : describe the picture of the cat being a cat si the computer can understand and use the picture
obfuscate the fact that you are/ were a waste
difficulty to conteste optmisation, necessity to talk in this laangage
relation between german pension fonds, sustained by people who want's to defend the rights of german and investiss in mines in south africa with awfull work condition : who is being optimised ?
for your info, a pot is a dyke in dutch :)
Damages :
One by axel
One by Dona
+ list of damage
Dividing on 2 or 3 groups, and do analysis
20 minutes
- to decide how we work
- interviewing the damage
50 minutes to do the analytics
***----------
Notes after the session
Tiine: the problem of abstracting, how can it make any sense if the meaning of the symbols change all the time.
Trained tree
- the interview of the damage is inside the formula
- only one queering
(flip human in trees and trees in human)
- need more time symbols/handle different timescales
- no sign for propagate, might need to add
- new sign/logical operation = ! (to say: negation of difference)
- did not really activate aethics/kapital -- framed the formula. This is a framing possibility, would be interesting to have more.
- ^ as shorthand
- applied flip (but love could have worked too): shaping/train humans by trees
result:
multiplied repair
flipped damage
humans are full of love (really?)
creativity multiplied (or boredom?)
Damage from tree morphic vision?
Database anxiety
http://etherbox.constantvzw.org/pad/p/queeranalytics.databaseanxiety
Analysis proliferates, instructions need to invite to cut down
Time needs to be a more prominent agent somehow
Giampilieri
Trying to be super precise
Interesting to go through everything
Did we think it was helpful, could change the damage?
Yes, it is changing the angle, it is therapeutic, it opens perspective
Symbols doubles the vocabulary -- a different lense/lenses
A way to do therapy disguised as analytics
Nice that is collective, conversation